|
Personal music players like the iPod are great. Thanks to these nifty little gadgets we are able to carry around more CDs worth of music than ever before, of course there are also unfortunate side effects. Take for example my current project of ripping various children's music CDs and loading them on the pod. While it's great to have kid friendly favorites on tap and at the ready these infectious songs unfortunately take up a lot of space and have a bad habit of finding their way into my "shuffle" play list. The other major problem with a portable music device is that the more you listen to the same old playlists the less time you spend discovering new music.
Thankfully there are services available that can help even those stuck in the 80s to contemporize. Various coworkers have recommended Rhapsody, Napster and even XM radio but by far my favorite is Pandora. I like the service not because it's free but because it uses a very sophisticated system called the music genome project. The function of the "project" is to assign gene characteristics to every song in its vast catalog and to therefore identify relationships between similar types of music. The result is a music searching system that relies less historical purchase data or user recommendations and more on limited criteria and the kinship of music.
By far the easiest and most enjoyable way to use the service is to simply look up your favorite artist and create a station. Pandora immediately plays another "related" artist that it deems to be in the same vein and for the most part the recommendations are spot on. In fact I decided to put the service to the test and created a station with two seed artists which comprise a large portion of my music collection. What I found is that 80% of the time Pandora played songs within an acceptable range and at least 25% of the time recommended tracks from artists that I already own.
Obviously there is a learning curve involved as the system adapts based on feedback in the form of thumbs up / thumbs down ratings. In most cases I found that Pandora would stop playing crap music when I thumbed down two or more tracks that I didn't like. But the system is not perfect and in a few cases I had to use the "this isn't what this station should play" rating to rid myself of troublesome music. I found that if I first asked "why is this song playing" I could isolate the characteristic that lead Pandora's algorithm down the wrong path and retroactively thumbs down any songs of similar style.
The major draw back to Pandora is that it streams, albeit with very light network traffic. The service is also ad supported and features Flash and JavaScript ads that are sometimes annoying and occasionally prone to malfunction. I also found the volume control the be a bit awkward and the limitation of skipping only six songs per hour frustrating when I backed myself into a corner of bad music.
The verdict is that if your looking to discover new music on the cheap Pandora is the way to go. In most cases if you start with music you really like and that is limited to a specific genre you will very easily find tunes that you are happy with. Sure your station may take a bit of tweaking but in the end you'll have something you can listen to for and hour or two and discover great new tracks. If you're curious you can check out my test stations Great Big Folk (featuring Great Big Sea and Stan Rogers) and Country Troubadour (featuring Johnny Cash, Waylon Jennings, Kris Kristofferson, Jerry Jeff Walker, Steve Earle, Billy Joe Shaver, Doc Watson).
View my profile
|